January 27th, 2009
Mainstreaming? What do YOU think?
After I posted a post (kind of a redundant phrase, eh?) to Twitter Moms, specifically the Mom’s of Special Needs Kids group, announcing my new unit study about dogs which went up yesterday, I received this reply from a commenter:
Nostalchick said:
Valid points made about the factory mentality of the education "system" but, what about the benefits of mainstreaming? As a mother of an HFA 9 yr old, I will tell you that the mainstream has helped him be prepared for the real world. I’ve always kind of thought that homeschooling avoids it.
There are good teachers out there and if you do your homework as a parent, you can implement specific things in your child’s IEP which is their right.
I’m just saying, we can boo hoo our schools but, it’s the world we live in and they must be prepared for that. Other great programs out there will show them other sides as well. Sports, art classes, music… all serve to teach us and our kids who they are.
Julie- CA.
Evidently she was talking about yesterday’s post which included some quotes from Seth Godin’s book, Purple Cow. Anyway, here was my reply on Twitter Moms:
Mainstreaming. Hmmmm…. I’ve never been a big fan of the mainstream. Yes, kids grow up and have to live in the real world. But is school anything like the real world? I don’t think so. Maybe in some ways it resembles the corporate world, but that’s a whole new issue.
I don’t mean to demonize the entire educational system. And it seems to work moderately well for some kids. Personally, the amazing difference in my ADD brother-in-law since starting homeschooling, both academically and socially is enough for me. And I’ve seen this in other ADD kids, too.
Any thoughts from our subscribers or visitors? (Click on the title of this post and then scroll down to the Comment box to let us know your thoughts.)
My comments on other blogs (and the comments of others that I responded to):